Over Size Chandelier Shades - Yes Or No?

I've been seeing this around, a big drum shade plopped over a chandelier. Kind of the antitheses of all the little small shades we usually use. I can't decide if I like it or not, or if it's a trend that will become a classic and here to stay. What do you think?

I like this

Mirror ceiling medallion $1400.
Neiman Marcus HERE
But I can't afford it

A kit - the cord $28. -the shade $375.
Comes in several colors
You can transform your chandelier
From Neiman Marcus HERE

Or you can forget about the big shade
and just get this wall light
Stretched canvas over a fluorescent light
$450. from designpublic.com HERE

The drum shade is the chandelier
$450. from lekkerhome HERE

Silver and glass $630.
From Neiman Marcus HERE

No.
But if you like it - $800. at Needless Mark Up

$3700. at Neiman Marcus HERE